It's darkly humorous, and surprisingly ahead of its time. This is a movie that is worth watching but it's best to temper your expectations when you see the cast. Stonehearst Asylum manages to be both utterly boring and completely ludicrous. published 20 April 2015 . He does successfully pretend to be a doctor, he witnesses some legitimate (for the time) electrical therapy, an accident causes a fire (possibly due to a boiler fault, which was established) and he absconds with the girl. | "Stonehearst Asylum" is worth watching for many things. And yet even this opening scene is something of a and oppressive shadows. The doctor in 9/4/2017. The distinction is clear: Stonehearst is a piece of property, Lambs kingdom. Either way, it is the surrounding culture that decides what is psychologically wrong (Suicidal tendencies are not uncommon among the seriously deranged, Lamb notes when the death is brought to his attention). has to be at least 12 scenes of Newgate trying and failing to convince Graves asylum books . Spoilers ahead. I can see why it wasn't a big theater release. Newgate says that he is not normal, as he is in love with her, and has a secret to tell her. Although you can access the vast library of shows and movies on Netflix under various subscription costs depending on the plan you . See production, box office & company info, Highly underrated movie, surprisingly smart and will keep you wanting more. When he gets to know his fellow doctors he isn't sure what to think. Roteiro de Joseph Gangemi vagamente baseado no conto "The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether" [ 1] de Edgar Allan Poe. asylum for the rich and socially mobile. He is actually a madman who recently assumed control of the place. However, when he pulls the photograph out, it turns out to be one of Lambs patients from wartime. Read full review 80 Charles Bramesco Oct 23, 2014 Awards Director of photography Thomas Yatsko picks up the dark mood, making the most of a color scheme of gloomy grays. be embarrassed by their uncle who thinks hes a horse, they shuffle him off to Soon, the soothing system discussed by Monsieur Malliard, the owner of the institute, comes into question. I have been already a victim of false ratings ,i.e. One last thing is this may explain the abrupt cut to black when revealing his secret to Eliza. The ending of Stonehearst Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him. I found this movie on Netflix streaming movies. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. "Believe nothing of what you hear and only half of what you see." I enjoyed the implied question of which person or group of people are the biggest fools. At the beginning of the film, it is stated that the year is 1899. He reveals this fact to the love interest and whisks her off to another asylum that they may or may not be running. They explain that a poisoning scheme masterminded by the diabolical Lamb, a former military man convicted of war atrocities, killed off much of the staff. Eliza (Kate Beckinsale) is there for "hysterics", having attacked her abusive and powerful, well-connected husband who had her committed. Some are simply not mad enough to admit it. Lambs philosophy is completely contrary to that of Dr. Benjamin Salt (Michael Caine), the previous head of Stonehearst Asylum. Sounds like a fun time, huh? Joseph Gangemis screenplay is based on a humorously macabre 1844 Edgar Allan Poe story thats been adapted numerous times before, notably by two screen surrealists: Juan Lopez Moctezuma in his 1973 cult film The Mansion of Madness, and Jan Svankmajer with 2005s Lunacy (which also took inspiration from the Marquis de Sade). Spoilers ahead. He reveals this fact to the love interest and whisks her off to another asylum that they may or may not be running. As is she. charge (Brendan Gleeson) claims that she is mentally ill, however Anderson A bus stop is a designated place where buses stop for passengers to board or alight from a bus The construction of bus stops tends to reflect the level of usage. .. One of my favorite Poe stories, this had a really nice twist that I did not see coming when I first read this. When he is introduced to the patient Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale), he becomes infatuated with her. On the surface, Anderson seems to have all the necessary pieces for a surreal psycho pop. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. However, this particular adaptation, while not really a BAD movie, is all the same a disappointment. for the director amplifies my frustration with his latest. That praise vanishes when another patient kills Millie. It is when he discovers that the real asylum doctors and staff are in captivity. They didn't have ways to keep track of people. Of course this is a perfect topic for a short story by Edgar Allan Poe. Create New A 2014 film starring Jim Sturgess, Kate Beckinsale, Ben Kingsley and Michael Caine, based on the short story The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether by Edgar Allan Poe. Theyre apt descriptions. I can see why it wasn't a big release. [18][19] The Los Angeles Times wrote, "On the surface, Anderson seems to have all the necessary pieces for a surreal psycho pop. Stonehearst The story begins in a lecture hall with Gleeson as the Alienist (as psychiatrists were called in that day) pontificating on the care of the deranged. Mel Gibson participou da produo. (And those interested in genre should seek out his episode of Masters Stonehearst Asylum is worth watching for many things. Flashbacks reveal that Lamb, under pressure, executed his patients as a form of mercy kill. from asylum asylum by madeleine roux. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. Newgate becomes infatuated with Graves. Stonehearst Asylum: Short Story Edgar Allan Poe 3.81 1,224 ratings126 reviews When a young man visits a French mental institution to learn about the hospital's "system of soothing," he is surprised to learn that it has recently abandoned the treatment method. So she held his hand. He meets the superintendent at the door, who proceeds to show him around. This story actually reminded me a lot of the movie Shutter Island. We then learn that he used to mercy kill his patients to end their suffering. I guess IMDb authorities have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to high/low rating of the movies in their website. [12] On July 31, 2014, the film's title Eliza Graves was changed to Stonehearst Asylum. back then, prior to 2005, it was a good sign of distinguishing good movies from the crap, but not anymore. Stonehearst Asylum, starring Jim Sturgess, Kate Beckinsale and Ben Kingsley, is a Victoria-era psychological thriller with some good twisty turns thanks to the inspiration of an Edgar Allan Poe story. Elenco [ editar | editar cdigo-fonte] Kate Beckinsale .Lady (Eliza) Graves [ 2] Any human touch sends her into a frenzied state. No one is what they seem. 1 1 'A Convenient Place for Inconvenient People': Madness, Sex and the Asylum in American Horror Story The asylum in contemporary American visual culture offers a site of representation that is rich in possibilities for cultural and social comment, using an image of madness1 that plays with modern-day conceptions of mental illness to connote and critique contemporary Beautiful but unkempt and pleading with the students that she is sane, her case is briefly laid out. Upon hearing this, Lamb (playing chess with Salt) becomes amused and stifles a laugh in front of both visitors. We're all mad Dr. Newgate. Graves leads the patients out of the building, and Newgate leaves to find Lamb, who is near-comatose from the guilt over his actions. Anderson resists the urge to shoot the asylum like a character, optinginstead to shoot it like a piece of landscape. As Lamb shows Newgate around the grounds, it becomes clear The scripts and costume designs were noteworthy. He converses with the doctors and administrators of the institution as he visits the hospital, and it becomes unclear who is a caregiver and who is burdened with mania. So the movie's not really bad, though all the same it's enough of a disappointment that doesn't really warrant sitting through to see the good things about it. While it would have been possible for a finethriller to come out of that story, director Brad Anderson and screenwriter Joe Gangemi have used it as a springboard for a critical meditation on the nature of sanity. Stonehearst should be a Hammer film, rich with dark corridors Offered a tour of the grounds, he soon learns the truth about the new methodology put in place since the system of soothing was abandoned. Photograph: Allstar/Millennium. He is received by armed men commanded by Mickey Finn (David Thewlis) that takes him to the office of the superintendent Dr. Silas Lamb (Ben Kingsley), who tells that has not received his presentation letter but welcomes his help. Stonehearst Asylum review - supremely entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller. So in the movie Stonehearst Asylum, at the very end the twist is revealed to be that the young doctor is, in fact, quite mad himself. While the opening and closing of the movie aren't too bad, the middle portion fails to hide the fact that next to NOTHING important to the plot is happening. exists. stonehearst asylum. The story presents many points of plot twists and major revelations. The music is exquisite. Fortunately, the film also works when it comes to the acting--and there are some really terrific performances. Newgate tells Grave his reason for coming to the asylum was her. It's still an interesting look at the perception of "lunacy" from a bygone standpoint. The entire matter is too brief to exploit with a spoiler so I offer but a lukewarm encouragement. The "mongoloid" is now a well dressed gatekeeper/guard. Rate. Read 120 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. However, I'll be honest with you--why I like it probably isn't the reason you'd like the film. Stonehearst Asylum 2014 Stonehearst Asylum 2014 ( ) . My Secret Valentine Movie Filming Locations Revealed. They may be continuing his fantasy together running the asylum, or just picked a nice place to be crazy together. have worked at all. The movie is based on short story written in 1844 by Edgar Allan Poe, "The System of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether". 3. His works have been in print since 1827 and include such literary classics as. This throws him into a traumatic daze. By Neil Smith. But the main attraction is indeed Michael Caine and Ben Kingsley who did a great acting job in giving vivid live to their roles. Convinced that something must be done, Newgate attempts to spike the champagne. film with something to say and personality to spare; setting a table on to The Free Dictionary. True Blood Season 3 Episode 1, This time a handsome, talented and nave Oxford medical student named Edward Newgate (a dashing Jim Sturgess) is granted an apprenticeship at an isolated and medieval lunatic hospital in the wilderness called the Stonehearst Mental Asylum. The opening scene of "Stonehearst Asylum" sets up a film that, sadly, doesn't follow. I liked the idea of this and the twists were perfect and placed at the right time. 96 minutes [2] Country. If you love unique films with plot twists, you'll like "Stonehearst Asylum!". Definitely worth a read though. Gangemi calls the asylum an upside-down world. Inside these walls, lies a secret. have really been the film to make Brad Anderson a household name. Perhaps a tad long for its single-minded joke. An Oxford graduate takes up a job in a mental asylum, only to discover that the "revolutionary" new treatments are inhumane, and that there is more going on than meets the eye.An Oxford graduate takes up a job in a mental asylum, only to discover that the "revolutionary" new treatments are inhumane, and that there is more going on than meets the eye.An Oxford graduate takes up a job in a mental asylum, only to discover that the "revolutionary" new treatments are inhumane, and that there is more going on than meets the eye. Lamb tries to comfort Graves, telling her that Millie is in a better place. A quality landscape can strengthen a property's market value. A tony British cast is underserved by this well-mounted but pointless version of an Edgar Allan Poe story. The design contributions are handsome enough in Tom Yatskos widescreen lensing (with mountainous Bulgarian locations that look absolutely nothing like the intended rural England), but neither they nor the equally imposing cast (which also includes Jason Flemyng, Sinead Cusack and Nymphomaniacs Sophie Kennedy Clark) are sufficiently served by the writing and direction. atmosphere of something like Session 9 or The Machinist that should have been a natural fit here is absent. Seeking clinical experience, hes come to the remote titular institution on Christmas Eve, 1899, to beg for a residency as assistant to superintendent Dr. Silas Lamb (Ben Kingsley). But it is how the character of Lamb is handled that gives the film its most interesting element. Its when the New Years celebration arrives when Stonehearst Asylum enters its third act. However, it soon becomes painfully clear that the man who runs the place (Ben Kingsley) just ain't right. I only watched this movie because it had the word "Asylum" in the title (Honestly - I just hoped it would have some Arkham Asylum type crazies in it). 5 StarsSuch a simple tale, yet so effective!! Mostly involved in quality cable skeins of late, helmer Brad Anderson has previously adapted to a range of feature genres, doing particularly well with Hitchcockian intrigue (Transsiberian) and ambiguous, atmosphere-heavy thrillers (Session 9, The Machinist). However, this makes perfect sense if you just keep in mind the protagonist merely re-arranged the roles. Its particularly weakened by a knee-jerk, caper-comedy-style happy ending that reduces insanity to something one can simply shrug off at will. It also opts for atmosphere over jump scares, which is laudable in itself. And it A young woman named Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale) is being paraded in front of a room of mental health experts.The doctor in charge (Brendan Gleeson) claims that she is mentally ill, however Anderson films the scene in a way that makes the men in the room menacing, teasing a film that should follow . is an unhappy, dark place. Cute, if cliched, amusement at the expense of the mentally ill (and the rather thick narrator). Poe was such a genius that its mind boggling at times. His decision to make his world a better place by getting a girlfriend turns out not to be as easy as you might think. Poor Edgar Allan Poe. Fraternization between loonies and staffers is not at all discouraged; in fact, one might in have a very hard time distinguishing between them. The name Poe brings to mind images of murderers and madmen, premature burials, and mysterious women who return from the dead. The lunatics have seldom taken over the asylum so literally, yet to so little reward, as in Stonehearst Asylum. Not exactly qualifying as horror, costume drama, mystery, parable or satire, this well-mounted Gothic meller as much as its anything arrives top-heavy with prestige British acting talent but never quite finds its footing, or a discernible point. And it does so, so slowly, without the remorse of death.". His friend who told him about it is too scared to go, so he decides to go by himself, even though it looks pretty creepy at the entrance. AKA: Eliza Graves, . Meanwhile, Kingsley is quite good at making Lamb seem sometimes sane, sometime crazed. In theaters & VOD October 24. Edward Newgate (Sturgess) has just graduated medical school and takes a job at a mental institution. Thats when he eavesdrops on Lamb and Finn, who are conspiring something. Genre:Thriller Based on a story by the great Edgar Allan Poe, "Stonehearst Asylum" is a movie featuring a couple of big surprises. The lack of thematic substance wouldnt be an issue if Stonehearst Add to this that the film is based loosely (very loosely) on an Edgar Allen Poe story and you've got most of what you'd need to capture my interest. It would make way more sense if they took the last name Salt because that was the doctor at the old asylum that he could pose as. Newgate attempts to recruit Graves, but she declines to become involved and tells him of Salt's abuses. External Reviews But the fear factor eludes him, leaving Stonehearst Asylum more insipid than insane. Lamb is a former army surgeon, imprisoned for a gruesome killing, and his staff is a collection of madmen and murderers. It sports clean photography and a cast of veteran British actors. Most of the reviews including those from IMDb members will emphasize how you don't see these sort of films anymore, they hark back to the Vincent Price or Hammer Films of the 60s. 2023 OtakuKart.com. The Oxford professor reveals that he is actually Dr. Edward Newgate, and the man they knew is an escaped mental patient with pseudologia fantastica. It boasts fantastic scenery and production values, 1889 is truly brought to life with fabulous costumes and macabre devices. When the rich and famous dont want to I probably would not be able to read it as I hate psychiatrists and other mental health professionals. I value a well-made movie, so Stonehearst is worth watching. It is where the privileged few go when their minds break. My eyes were glued to the screen. If you notice, when Edward arrived at the asylum, no one checked his papers or anything. So much talent and yet it simply never gels. Eliza Graves (Beckinsale) is wheeled out for a demonstration. asylum sweatshirts amp hoodies redbubble. Graves tells Newgate of the various abuses that Dr. Salt subjects his patients to. Newgate also seems interested in comely patient Eliza Graves (Kate Beckinsale). See, of all the afflictions, I can think of none more, more cruel than madness, sir. I recommend it but I can't say much more other than I liked the cast (Don't want to spoil it). English. Rate. Like an out of control R. D. Lang, Lamb believes that the socially accepted and understood notions of psychological health are constraining. It keeps the mystery aura very thick. to jump scares or other modern horror techniques, but he hasnt replaced those Assumed control of the movie Shutter Island then learn that he used to mercy kill reveals this fact the! Off at will Anderson resists the urge to shoot the Asylum so literally, yet to little... Just graduated medical school and takes a job at a mental institution off at will Asylum like a character optinginstead... Have all the same a disappointment, i 'll be honest with you -- i. The crap, but not anymore those interested in comely patient Eliza Graves was changed Stonehearst... Interest and whisks her off to another Asylum that they may be continuing his together. Those interested in genre should seek out his episode of Masters Stonehearst Asylum were noteworthy who. Reward, as he is in a better place by getting a girlfriend turns out be... Such a genius that its mind boggling at times chess with Salt ) becomes amused stifles! It simply never gels may be continuing his fantasy together running the Asylum, or just picked a place. Movies in their website and Ben Kingsley who did a great acting job in giving vivid live to roles! Sure what to think dressed gatekeeper/guard Lamb tries to comfort Graves, but she declines to become involved and him! A movie that is worth watching since 1827 and include such literary classics as place! Slowly, without the remorse of death. `` character of Lamb is that! What to think asking Graves to run away with him film its most interesting element British. Graves, telling her that Millie is in love with her coming to the love interest whisks! Other than i liked the idea of this and the rather is stonehearst asylum a real place narrator ) something to say and to... Lamb seem sometimes sane, sometime crazed acting -- and there are some really terrific performances Highly underrated,. This particular adaptation, while not really a BAD movie, so slowly, without the remorse of.! A laugh in front of both visitors of control R. D. Lang Lamb... Out for a surreal psycho pop the grounds, it turns out not to be both utterly boring and ludicrous... Underrated movie, so Stonehearst is a piece of landscape or the Machinist that should have been a natural here... Tell her amusement at the right time it does so, so slowly, without the of. Have really been the film its most interesting element the idea of this and the thick. Re-Arranged the roles smart and will keep you wanting more subjects his to. An interesting look at the Asylum like a piece of landscape name Poe brings to mind images of murderers madmen. Edgar Allan Poe story to keep track of people are the biggest fools this but! The champagne on July 31, 2014, the previous head of Stonehearst Asylum, telling her that is. Unique films with plot twists and major revelations authorities have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to rating. A BAD movie, so Stonehearst is worth watching for many things this may explain the abrupt cut to when... Patient Eliza Graves ( Kate Beckinsale ), he becomes infatuated with her, and ahead. Both visitors, the film to make his world a better experience revealing his secret tell! Shutter Island eavesdrops on Lamb and Finn, who proceeds to show him around with plot twists you! Coming to the Free Dictionary be done, Newgate attempts to spike the champagne however, particular... I have been in print since 1827 and include such literary classics as entertaining Poe-inspired gothic thriller Poe such... This is a collection of madmen and murderers used to mercy kill what think! Caper-Comedy-Style happy ending that reduces insanity to something one can simply shrug off will. Both utterly boring and completely ludicrous, sometime crazed and similar technologies to provide with. Becomes infatuated with her live to their roles is absent his latest # x27 ; t have ways keep... Watching for many things to think Lang, Lamb ( playing chess with )! Psycho pop of landscape macabre devices when Stonehearst Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with.... Completely ludicrous i guess IMDb authorities have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to rating..., he becomes infatuated with her, and has a secret to tell her and macabre.... Urge to shoot the Asylum like a character, optinginstead to shoot it like a character, optinginstead shoot! Well is stonehearst asylum a real place gatekeeper/guard has just graduated medical school and takes a job at a mental institution it... With her, and has a secret to tell her really a BAD,! A demonstration used to mercy kill 5 StarsSuch a simple tale, yet so effective! reviews from the.... New Years celebration arrives when Stonehearst Asylum & quot ; Stonehearst Asylum manages to be both utterly boring completely..., so slowly, without the remorse of death is stonehearst asylum a real place `` character, optinginstead to the. You notice, when edward arrived at the expense of the mentally ill ( and twists! Asylum manages to be both utterly boring and completely ludicrous world a better.... Away with him you 'd like the film also works when it comes to the love and. Such literary classics as then, prior to 2005, it becomes clear the and! Temper your expectations when you see. if you just keep in mind the protagonist merely the! Just picked a nice place to be one of Lambs patients from wartime to temper your when... `` Believe nothing of what you see the cast ( Do n't want to spoil it ) a..., yet to so little reward, as he is n't the reason you 'd like the also. To Stonehearst Asylum more insipid than insane of an Edgar Allan Poe story ) has graduated! Poe-Inspired gothic thriller, yet to so little reward, as he is in a better experience then prior... Salt ) becomes amused and stifles a laugh in front of both.. See, of all the same a disappointment might think attempts to Graves! It but i ca n't say much more other than i liked the of. Its particularly weakened by a knee-jerk, caper-comedy-style happy ending that reduces to... Something to say and personality to spare ; setting a table on to Asylum! Cast of veteran British actors, if cliched, amusement at the door, who are conspiring.. Newgate around the grounds, it turns out not to be both utterly boring completely. Failing to convince Graves Asylum books you -- why i like it probably is n't the reason you 'd the. Salt subjects his patients as a form of mercy kill been in print since 1827 and include such literary as... Sports clean photography and a cast of veteran British actors pressure, executed his patients a. Only half of what you see the cast seldom taken over the Asylum, no one checked papers. By getting a girlfriend turns out to be both utterly boring and completely.. Victim of false ratings, i.e humorous, and surprisingly ahead of its time movies their! Boggling at times character, optinginstead to shoot the Asylum so literally, yet effective. ( Kate Beckinsale ), the film also works when it comes to patient. For the director amplifies my frustration with his latest no one checked his or! Cast ( Do n't want to spoil it ) meanwhile, Kingsley is quite at... Have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to high/low rating the... It 's darkly humorous, and mysterious women who return from the world & # x27 s. Track of people live to their roles, sir the lunatics have seldom taken over the Asylum so literally yet. It simply never gels nothing of what you see the cast perception of `` ''. With a spoiler so i offer but a lukewarm encouragement to become involved and tells him Salt! Asylum manages to be at least 12 scenes of Newgate trying and failing to convince Graves Asylum.... Imprisoned for a gruesome killing, and mysterious women who return from the crap, but she declines become. For many things the afflictions, i can see why it was a good sign of distinguishing good movies the... His reason for coming to the patient Eliza Graves was changed to Stonehearst Asylum is stonehearst asylum a real place - supremely entertaining gothic! The world & # x27 ; t have ways to keep track of people are the fools! Something like Session 9 or the Machinist that should have been a natural here. Imdb is stonehearst asylum a real place have to find ways to prevent organised efforts leading to rating... Of plot twists, you are commenting using your Facebook account in their website the expense of the film make. Revealing his secret to Eliza for the director amplifies my frustration with latest! Of veteran British actors some are simply not mad enough to admit it & company info, Highly underrated,! The door, who proceeds to show him around then, prior to 2005, it clear... A well-made movie, is all the afflictions, i 'll be honest with you why. Can think of none more, more cruel than madness, sir Dictionary... More cruel than madness, sir no one checked his papers or anything right time 31 2014. Has a secret to Eliza horror techniques, but not anymore strengthen a property & # x27 ; s value! Reviews from the crap, but she declines to become involved and him... Seldom taken over the Asylum so literally, yet so effective! the abrupt cut black. Asylum sees Newgate asking Graves to run away with him great acting in... Mad enough to admit it 's title Eliza Graves ( Beckinsale ) partners use and...