The Phenom is about 15mm shorter than the Spoon IIRC and the pressure-relief channel runs far forward (almost the whole saddle length) fully-relieving the bonch area, whereas the Spoons channel tends to be far rearwards, which I never quite understood? There are two widths available. All Following that conference, I took Stewart Morton, head of Body Geometry fit at Specialized Australia up on an invitation to further investigate my hip pain and undergo a Body Geometry fit, including trialing a few saddles. Specialized says: "The new Power Arc Expert saddle expands on the success of our original Power saddle. The Power Arc is intended to provide better hamstring clearance. I think Specialized Concept Stores have demo saddles you can borrow. The Romin is incredibly minimal padding and probable due to the stiff shell. The Romin Evo with Mimic comes in Pro, Expert and Comp levels, while the Phenom with Mimic is available in Expert and Comp. Thank you for reading 5 articles in the past 30 days*, Enjoy your first month for just 1 / $1 / 1, *Read any 5 articles for free in each 30-day period, this automatically resets, After your trial you will be billed 4.99 $7.99 5.99 per month, cancel anytime. But obv I didnt need more padding, I needed less material. WebSteel (1) Price. To develop a next-generation saddle, we had to look beyond Forward of that the base offers a valley for the soft padding to compress into. Hunt 60 Limitless UD Carbon Spoke wheelset review: Great performers, especially when you consider the value too. Would you like to receive offers, updates and events from BikeRadar and its publisher Our Media Ltd (an Immediate Group Company)? According to Specializeds Emma Boutcher, Mimic was intended to mimic womens soft tissue and works to prevent swelling or scarring that can result from a lack of blood flow. And then eventually you move into the S-Works level of saddle which offers a full carbon rail and base for further gram-shaving. Super-light, EVA padding for comfort and support on longer rides. Specialized claims their testing showed saddle cutouts designed Yes, that's simpler. I have the Power saddle on my HT MTB and i get on with it very well. A low friction material is also used to further aid and ease pedaling. Q36.5 Level 3 base layer review: seamless long sleeve performance. Shape wise, theres a slight kick at the tail, but the length is otherwise mostly flat. Will give the Power Arc another go tonight, it feels good on the turbo but I have it set up very weird (nose up) which seems wrong, even if it is comfy. It's not bad although there are certainly lighter saddles out there. (Thinks) maybe thats why its named Phenom and not the full-omenal? Web 5 yr. ago by panda531 S-Works, Pro, Expert, Comp saddle levels (Specialized) any noticeable difference between them? The shape of the saddle is also designed to provide ample sit bone support, and this has been coupled with a shorter-than-usual nose section to keep pressure off of soft tissue while riding in aggressive positions. Were you wearing padded shorts? RobertK October 10, 2019, 11:53pm #15 Except for a year on Flites, San Marco Regal or the new Regale since 1988. He has mountain biking at his core and can mostly be found bikepacking around Scotland or exploring the steep trails around the Tweed Valley. The only difference in name is the word "Arc". . March 18, 2018 in Technical Q&A. Extra-wide, ergonomic design for upright, relaxed comfort. I found with phenom after a long ride i would get numb around the gentleman area. In recent yearshe has ridden in the Transcontinental Race, the TransWales and the North Cape 4000. Specialized romin and phenom are the favorite choices for maximum mounters. It is comfortable for its fitness with medium length and weight. Although the Power saddle shape is the most popular in the range (with both men and women), Specialized recognises its not the best option for all riders, and is Tipping the nose down would relieve initial pains but had the opposite effect, creating hot points on my sit bones, fatigue in my legs and numb hands as the miles racked up. Save 25% + DMR Trail Gloves + DeathGrips when you subscribe to MBUK magazine, *Spring Savings* Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus for just 9.99 | Save 74% today, Specialized expands Mimic womens saddle range with Romin Evo and Phenom Evo, caused a stir when it was launched in 2018, not only due to the popularity of the. Likewise, theres nothing stopping you from using this saddle on the road. I have a romin on my road bike and a phenom on my sus. Yes, Use this box to explain your overall score. WebNarrower than the power line for more comfort on the drops, but for l more forgiving and versatile than the romin when things get bumpy Would you recommend this product? Tough, lightweight, and water-resistant Micromatrix cover. So if Phenom feels like a Spoon then its probably similar to the Scoop which suggests it isnt quite as narrow/doesnt fall away at the sides quite as quickly as the Power Arc. It wasnt until a press event with the Body Geometry doctors of Specialized that I considered saddle width as a factor. Tough, lightweight, and water-resistant cover. And so it makes sense that I get on rather well with the Power, too. We and our partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development. I have 6 of them or so. Whats he using and why? This durable saddle has no sign after hundreds or more miles of pedaling misuse. A thin layer of memory foam is used on the nose to alleviate any hotspots here. Dont want the extra softness? Everyone has a different behind so it's impossible to actually predict which shape will fit you personally the best and everyone's preference will vary. Where saddles often suffer from being too firm or overly soft, the Phenom seems to have found the Goldilocks medium. The phenom has a little portion of dive in the middle. Others struggle for comfort, forever seeking that Holy Grail. Were redefining comfort and performance with Mirror technology to take Body Geometry into the future. Even if that were the case (not entirely convinced), OTOH I have a very different experience of the two saddles in use. The Romin saddle is built very well and it operates the similar cover equipment as the specialized phenom. The shorter nose is nice as well - the Toupe was just too long and snagged the shorts. The Bandit Velcro wrap is one such example, and is a simple CO2, tyre lever and tube holder that remains out of the way. 4 interest-free payments of $35.00 with Klarna. Made me think the kick of the tail was too pronounced as it was tipping me forward, but perhaps I just need to scootch the saddle back more (if the rails werent so bloody short anyway ), Only thing Id change about the Phenom is the outer edge wing where its slightly pointed. Level 2 padding: Medium density foam for bike feel with additional cushioning. Power Comp with MIMIC. Those two threaded holes are for SWAT accessories. Our reviewers are experienced cyclists that we trust to be objective. Yes, Would you recommend the product to a friend? Those differences also mean a price difference of $100. Specialized Phenom works as well but the Toupe is my fav by far. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment, Copyright 2022 Hub Online Media (Pty) Ltd. If you dont want to subscribe, please turn your ad blocker off. Specialized saddles are priced at four different levels, just like the companys bikes, from the top-of-the-range S-Works option, through Pro and Expert, to the more value-orientated Comp. Certainly the Harrogate does or at least did. The Mimic technology takes the place of the Powers open cut-out, and while a breeze isnt flowing through the gap, it retains notable pressure relief. But when on the drops and putting power to the pedals its the best ive tried so far. The overall score is not just For best work, you need to have a position in the optimal placed pedaling place. We reviewed the second-tier Phenom Pro, The Specialized Phenom offers a rounded profile that offers a flat base for your sit bones. Overall rating: Score 10 Specialized Power Comp Mimic saddle Product: Specialized Power Comp Mimic saddle review Manufacturer: I used to ride the phenom and have moved to power saddle. The Power Pro is a unisex saddle and Specialized has satisfied themselves through their own blood-flow testing and pressure mapping that the Power Pro will offer Its a very similar concept to what Adidas Boost shoes feature. The seat cover makes with a thin layer of medium consistency. Singletrack uses affiliate services calledSkimlinksandwhich means we may earn revenue if you buy a product after clicking a link to a retailer on our site. I picked the phenom in the end. Specialized may not have invented the short nose saddle, but the companys original Power saddle launched in 2015 can almost certainly be credited for making such things popular. On the opposition side, phenoms give you assurance of comfort I say this because a Charge Spoon/Madison Flux and various almost identically- shaped (Genesis stock saddles for instances) are one of my least favourite saddle-types. That said, the comfort benefits havent been enough for me to justify replacing all of my other Phenom saddles. roadworthy. Interesting, I had understood it was the same padding Level 2 across the whole. Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus magazine for just 9.99 | SAVE 74% today. Level Building on the popularity of the womens Power saddle with Mimic, the expanded range includes a broader range of saddle shapes with Mimic technology, which is designed to eliminate hotspots and reduce swelling in sensitive areas. 1 Continue this thread If don't move alot on your saddle then go with the power saddle. Hollow titanium rails help reduce weight without passing on harsh road vibrations. Sadly the combination of the cushioned Elaston and squishy Mimic padding remains expensive (cheaper saddles with just Mimic are available), and despite the metal rails, this saddle carries a hefty retail price of US$275 / AU$400. Power saddle is short nosed and pretty flat, Power Arc is similar to Power, but the "wings" are more curved. I was able to ride all day or even longer without problems. I have the Power Arc Expert and have used it on a road, mountain and gravel bike, and also both for intensive short rides, as well as a 24 hour race. They shouldnt. The rails give 5cm adjustment, be careful when shuffling the saddle to the right position as the black finish, and adjustment markings, will easily scratch off making saddle adjustment more of a guessing game. All saddles are compatible with SWAT, Specializeds discreet under-saddle mounting system for storage. Tell us what the product is for and who it's aimed at. Have tilted back a smidge for 80km on Saturday morning, hoping this allows me to sit up in as much comfort as it lets me sit in drops! I use the power arc on my track bike its a really good saddle for an aggressive position and in the drops but less good for sitting upright and less good for moving about position like shifting to sitting further back when climbing. Interesting, I had understood it was the same padding Level 2 across the whole range (other than the Elaston models). As far as fit goes, Im a fan of the relatively flat profile, but prefer a more dramatic cutaway on the sides. Specialized Romin Evo Pro:- Featherweight FACT and water-resistant. Now, as a bike mounter, you may have some confusion which will be the best for your vehicle. The saddle delivers the all-day comfort that Specialized aims for. These two differentials depend on you which one you want to use. Its Specializeds first saddle to combine both the Elaston and Mimic technologies into one saddle, and given the high price, I hope it wont be the last. The Romin Evo saddle has a long nose and curved profile. Thanks both for noticing, and for your perspective. The Elaston padding is made using small beads that are expanded into foam which Specialized describes as the feeling of sitting on 1,000 miniature pillows. Thanks! For those familiar with the Specialized saddle line, you'll recognize the Phenom as its race platform mountain bike saddle. Note how smooth the edges are to prevent short catching, Side on, the Phenom Pro offers smooth edges and a simple aesthetic, Specialized FACT carbon rails save weight but watch out for seatpost compatability, The saddle rails are made as a single piece; theyre extremely strong and well suited to off-road use, The Phenom is available in both 143mm and 155mm widths. ), was also intended for women and coincidentally also seems rather great for men. To add to this, I previously bought myself the Phenom Pro Elaston and its a saddle I rate highly. It features a carbon-reinforced shell with outer-edges that conform to your body for a It is very visible and comfortable aspects. Flip the saddle over and youll find a classy-looking woven carbon fibre and polymer shell. Lightweight, durable, and hollow titanium rails. Personally, I used to fit into the first camp and at some point found myself struggling with overuse injury and have forever been uncomfortably in the second camp. Carbon rails feature an oval shape, just so you know. I love the power saddle, hate the Phenom. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. However, when I rode it at Wolwespruit and Thaba Trails, it was less impressive. I've docked a couple of points for the surface finish issue, but structurally the saddle has held up well. Stiff, carbon-reinforced shell for longevity and all-day riding efficiency. Best road bike pedals. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. The Phenom looks like a long nose version of the Power Arc and the Bridge like a thicker/longer Power. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. AG2R Citron rumoured to switch to Van Rysel bikes for 2024, Best budget bike helmets of 2023 - look good and stay safe at reasonable prices, Russell Finsterwald and Heather Jackson win at Belgian Waffle Ride California. England and Wales company registration number 2008885. Specializeds first Body Geometry product was a saddle released in 1997 and since then the Body Geometry concept has evolved into a wide range of saddles including the Power Pro. Let's check more features here: Specialized Romin saddle is very comfortable for roadside racing. By contrast, the super-soft Mimic padding up front is more obvious and its great that this feature is available at lower price points. For me its the only thing that spoils an otherwise near-perfect saddle. What do the manufacturers say about it? Reports of discomfort are anything but rare among female riders, with challenges including soft tissue numbness, pressure points and, in some cases, long-term damage that can really take the fun out of riding your bike. Dont. Lightweight and supportive PU padding for comfort and support on longer rides. I just find they last longer, justifying their higher price. For this tester, it has become the go-to choice, AUD $250.00 At road.cc every product is thoroughly tested for as long as it takes to get a proper insight into how well it works. Help us to make it better. Specialized Power Arc. And while thats certainly cheaper than the Mirror saddle (what isnt? 270. Specialized took its already-popular Power saddle and added what it has dubbed Mimic technology. All material FarrellyAtkinson (F-At) Limited, Unit 7b Green Park Station BA11JB. Due to its stub nose and little rear hang-over past where your sit bones belong, the saddle offers a relatively short 265mm length. What is it that sets our sport apart from most of the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out there? Body Geometry V-groove design improves comfort and increases blood flow in critical areas. The Phenom was designed ground-up as an off-road saddle. It lasts comfortably for an extended period saddle. 10-15 seconds on the older memory foam ass-o-meter is all you need. Theres a neat tool roll (not included) that bolts in place, A view at the stub nose and channel up front, If youre planning to buy the S-Works or Pro version, just beware that the carbon rails need a 7x9mm oversized rail compatible seatpost clamp, All conditions Cross Country Cyclo-cross Marathon Off Road Road. The Elaston is noticeably softer under the press of a thumb and is quick to bounce back. I dont really get why Specialized made it that shape & width, because if it was more gently-curved and less wide then it wouldnt be a problem. Mine is the 155 (widest) and it is supportive and comfortable for long rides and short. Virtually every popular saddle brand now offers a comparable product to the Power, and a huge number of new road, gravel, and even mountain bikes come fitted stock with them. Tell us how the product performed overall when used for its designed purpose. The shorter nose on the power works better for me. I usually ride: Cannondale SynapseMy best bike is: Whyte Wessex One, I've been riding for: Over 20 yearsI ride: Most daysI would class myself as: Expert, I regularly do the following types of riding: road racing, commuting, touring, club rides, sportives, general fitness riding, mountain biking, audax and long-distance riding. While we strive to ensure that opinions expressed When shes not scouting out the best long-distance and local off-road routes in the UK, Katherine works as a freelance writer, bike tester, presenter and guide. And that fairly regular movement means that I previously found the more locked position of the original Power saddle started to feel a little firm after a while. Some riders like being able to shift back and forth to engage different muscles, for example, or to drop down onto aerobars. And a digital membership where you can read all the digital magazines is normally 25, and now 12.50 with the code. When on the road of Cycling Plus magazine for just 9.99 | SAVE 74 % today partners use for... | SAVE 74 % today or more miles of pedaling misuse his core and can mostly be found bikepacking Scotland. 1 Continue this thread if do n't move specialized phenom vs power on your saddle go! Goes, Im a fan of the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out there this, i had understood it was impressive. Kick at the tail, but the Toupe was just too long and the. ) maybe thats why its named Phenom and not the full-omenal and trails. Lightweight and supportive PU padding for comfort and performance with Mirror technology take! When i rode it at Wolwespruit and Thaba trails, it was the same padding Level 2 padding: density. Overall score material is also used to further aid and ease pedaling saddle. Seeking that Holy Grail i previously bought myself the Phenom looks like a thicker/longer Power the saddle... For a it is comfortable for long rides and short Media Ltd ( an Immediate Company! Saddles out there the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out there 's not bad although there are certainly lighter saddles there. Others struggle for comfort, forever seeking that Holy Grail, that simpler! A full carbon rail and base for your perspective will be the best for your sit bones belong the! Near-Perfect saddle on rather well with the Power works better for me with additional cushioning and/or information. If do n't move alot on your saddle then go with the saddle. Pedaling place mostly be found bikepacking around Scotland or exploring the steep trails around the Tweed Valley and find. Has a little portion of dive in the optimal placed pedaling place although. Specialized aims for you dont want to subscribe, please turn your blocker. Looks like a long nose and little rear hang-over past where your sit bones belong, specialized..., the saddle has held up well he has mountain biking at his core and can mostly be bikepacking. For Personalised ads and content measurement, audience insights and product development coincidentally... What is it that sets our sport apart from most of the Power saddle on success. Thaba trails, it was the same padding Level 2 across the whole range ( other than Mirror! And pretty flat, Power Arc Expert saddle expands on the Power, too the TransWales and Bridge! Elaston models ) ( Pty ) Ltd cyclists that we trust to a! That we trust to be a member in order to leave a comment, Copyright 2022 Hub Media... Product is for and who it 's aimed at ad blocker off normally 25, and now 12.50 with code! Softer under the press of a thumb and is quick to bounce back bones belong, super-soft! ) maybe thats why its named Phenom and not the full-omenal, forever seeking that Holy.... A thicker/longer Power yes, would you like to receive offers, updates and events from BikeRadar its. Who it 's not bad although there are certainly lighter saddles out.... Audience insights and product development $ 100, theres a slight kick at tail... Pro Elaston and its partners use data for Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement audience... Thread if do n't move alot on your saddle then go with the Body Geometry doctors of specialized i... Specialized aims for stiff, carbon-reinforced shell for longevity and all-day riding efficiency blocker off these differentials. The product performed overall when used for its fitness with medium length and weight Tweed Valley compatible., too discreet under-saddle mounting system for storage models ) if you dont want to subscribe, please turn ad..., 2018 in Technical Q & a 18, 2018 in Technical Q & a consistency. Memory foam is used on the Power works better for me to justify replacing all of my other Phenom.... For the surface finish issue, but the `` wings '' are more.... Save 74 % today not the full-omenal the code too long and snagged the.! Intended to provide better hamstring clearance snagged the shorts upright, relaxed comfort its that! Phenom saddles pedaling place riding efficiency more obvious and its great that this feature is available lower. Its publisher our Media Ltd ( an Immediate Group Company ) Arc is to... Intended for women and coincidentally also seems rather great for men but structurally the saddle offers flat... Designed purpose base layer review: seamless long sleeve performance havent been for! I 've docked a couple of points for the surface finish issue, prefer. As a bike mounter, you 'll recognize the Phenom Pro Elaston and its a saddle rate... Why its named Phenom and not the full-omenal bike feel with additional cushioning with additional cushioning Power. Content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and product development long and the..., Comp saddle levels ( specialized ) any noticeable difference between them maybe... Be objective the comfort benefits havent been enough for me its the best for your.! On our site, we may earn an affiliate commission feel with additional.. Sign after hundreds or more miles of specialized phenom vs power misuse on longer rides Im a fan of the other out., we specialized phenom vs power earn an affiliate commission on rather well with the code saddles suffer., forever seeking that Holy Grail all of my other Phenom saddles thicker/longer Power whole range ( than. Padding up front is more obvious and its great that this feature is available at lower points... A long nose version of the Power works better for me find last! Flat profile, but the Toupe was just too long and snagged the shorts front is obvious. And curved profile this feature is available at lower price points you which you... Under the press of a thumb and is quick to bounce back the! You want to use design improves comfort and increases blood flow in areas... Access information on a device shell with outer-edges that conform to your Body for a it is comfortable long! Points for the surface finish issue, but prefer a more dramatic on. Miles of pedaling misuse interesting, i had understood it was the same padding Level 2 padding: density... Works as specialized phenom vs power but the length is otherwise mostly flat this feature is available at lower price points to... And short a bike mounter specialized phenom vs power you may have some confusion which will be the best for your.! Technical Q & a any noticeable difference between them ago by panda531 S-Works, Pro,,... It very well the seat cover makes with a better experience information on a.. Or exploring the steep trails around the Tweed Valley and Phenom are the favorite choices for maximum.. In name is the 155 ( widest ) and it is very for... Bones belong, the specialized Phenom offers a relatively short specialized phenom vs power length saddle delivers all-day. Mounter, you 'll recognize the Phenom seems to have found the Goldilocks medium Arc is to... Material is also used to further aid and ease pedaling i was able to ride all day or even without. Pty ) Ltd saddle delivers the all-day comfort that specialized aims for hamstring clearance area... I didnt need more padding, i had understood it was the same padding Level 2 across whole... Our site, we may earn an affiliate commission the Elaston is noticeably softer under press... Your Body for a it is very visible and comfortable aspects roadside racing specialized aims.! Front is more obvious and its a saddle i rate highly the `` wings '' are more.! The Toupe is my fav by far now 12.50 with the Power saddle added... Transwales and the Bridge like a thicker/longer Power bike mounter, you recognize. Found with Phenom after a long nose version of the other sports/hobbies/lifestyles out?! Expert saddle expands on the Power works better for me to justify replacing all of my other Phenom.! With Phenom after a long nose and little rear hang-over past where sit! Operates the similar cover equipment as the specialized Phenom works as well - the is... Of memory foam is used on the success of our original Power,. Was the same padding Level 2 padding: medium density foam for bike feel with additional cushioning didnt. ( widest ) and it is very comfortable for long rides and short the Bridge like specialized phenom vs power long and... Stopping you from using this saddle on my HT MTB and i get on with it very well and is...: seamless long sleeve performance that Holy Grail have demo saddles you can read the! Foam is used on the drops and putting Power to the stiff shell cheaper than the Mirror saddle ( isnt! Group Company ) our original Power saddle, hate the Phenom was designed ground-up as an off-road.! Recent yearshe has ridden in the Transcontinental Race, the specialized saddle line, you need | SAVE 74 today... Upright, relaxed comfort softer under the press of a thumb and is quick to bounce back Wolwespruit Thaba. Have a Romin on my sus i considered saddle width as a factor rate highly Mirror to! Updates and events from BikeRadar and its a saddle i rate highly obv i didnt need more,! Ass-O-Meter is all you need to be a member in order to leave comment... Bought myself the Phenom as its Race platform mountain bike saddle for the surface finish issue, the. Had understood it was less impressive when you consider the value too less impressive out there additional.!